You get a lifetime supply of pie
but
You can never have cake again
I will not


245 Comments

Top/Newest

the-idiotic-demiboyflux 4 years ago
asexuals be like: WHAT nO I CAnT Have My CaKe

Cumbercookie84 10 years ago
*dean frantically scrambles to press the button*

Starslayer 10 years ago
That is the funniest comment on this website😅

ElisabethSPN 10 years ago
*spn fan comes in hysterically laughing then starts to cry*

winchester_dean_sam 10 years ago
Yall this is supernatural! DEAN

Jacob Spivey 13 years ago
Bitch please, the cake was a lie anyway.

LittleKitten 4 years ago
I prefer birthday brownies.
Load more replies

sickasfrick 10 years ago
Dean Winchester would have pressed the button.

Archer_shoob 5 years ago
The cake is a LIE

ThePaulDude 10 years ago
THE CAKE IS A LIE!!!

$torm 10 years ago
so is ur mom

JAKTscene 11 years ago
Does ice cream cake count as cake? If so, no. Never.

rileysunshine12 10 years ago
@troompaloompa hes talking about icecream cake and yes that counts
Load more replies

Cheshire shadow 11 years ago
*dean licks his lips*

SAVVY_BOY 8 years ago
*nonstop throws pie at ex*

caden wayne 8 years ago
cheesecake pie .............anything can be a pie so long as theres crust around the filling

DrakeDes 9 years ago
Pumpkin pie is my favorite desert.... and cake is horrible for you.... win win!

jkmc1205 9 years ago
Maybe if it was the other way around, then yes.

Mitchell Child 13 years ago
DEAAAAN!!

MUNILADDBAE 10 years ago
Where are the supernatrual fans at 😂😂

purple-eyed-demon 9 years ago
Hello darling

problematic 11 years ago
DEAN WINCHESTER

Thomas Herndon 13 years ago
pie > cake

Lujain Samarkandi 13 years ago
cake flavored pie problem solved

YellowCandy8432 3 years ago
HOL UP HE GOT A .
Load more replies

UnicornEllie 7 years ago
I hate cake anyways.. Those with icing it"s super sweet

Chloena329 10 years ago
Time to make a cake pie.

BABYCOOLCOPS911THECOOLCOPS911 9 years ago
Yo I never cared about either but screw it blueberry pie her I come!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Martianova325 11 years ago
Fuck Pie, i've got cheese cake

that random girl 11 years ago
I'll open a pie shop :3

Alva_Cado 9 years ago
Pie

andy lol 11 years ago
I dont like cake lol

DarkmasterBlaze884 10 years ago
I never liked kake anywhays.

Sgt.Boris 12 years ago
What about some Cake flavored pie? Beside the cake was a lie

DatBoi21 8 years ago
CAKE > pie

the person your friends with but is wierd and gets on your nerves 11 years ago
uhh... can i have both

oldaccountidontusethis2 2 years ago
but cake is better than pie >:(

Alexbass303 10 years ago
Cakes a lie

Demigoddess13 12 years ago
Dean Winchester

KatieBates 9 years ago
Sam can never get Dean pie Again

Superpills 9 years ago
Pie = infinty Cake = a lie

Derpy02 11 years ago
Find the 2 and tomorrow youy will be kissed 555555555555555555555555555555555555555555555555555555555555555555555555555555555555555555555555555555555555555555255555555555555555555555555555555555555555555555555555555555555555555555555555555555555555.Count d... [Show full comment]

TheAwesomePurpleOwl 9 years ago
Universe explodes

Calmdown8 11 years ago
Lolololololololololololol

A rose for emily 10 years ago
Love me some pie

Frevaltlar 11 years ago
The cake is a lie.

mrcheese 6 years ago
upside?

TheTruePie 10 years ago
h3h3 PIE is da bessssst

Teriza Duck Marvell 13 years ago
Goin cakeless!

Tacofun24hi 10 years ago
Well, I don't like either, so let"s talk about terms of investing. If I had a lifetime supply of pie, I could easily open a pie shop. Given the extremely large supply, the store would last a substantially large period of time. Due to this, I would profit g... [Show full comment]

kylling 11 years ago
I h8 pie anyway

Floofula 8 years ago
Sell some pie, make profit, buy dream life. I can give up cake for that

creepercrew23 10 years ago
I don't like cake

ignition191 9 years ago
guaranteed pie or not guaranteed cake? i think its obvious!

frenchfries 11 years ago
cake > pie

Creeperkiller2000 9 years ago
Sorry Jimbo. I guess we"re all out of cake
Load more comments


© WillYouPressTheButton.com • since 2013
Stats • Contact Us • EULA • Privacy policy